| Rev. Father Smith | 1852-1853 |
| Rev. K. Obranagan | 1854, 1858-1865(66) |
| Rev. Father McConnel | 1857(58) |
| Father Byrne (Burns) | Assistant |
| Father Pugh | |
| Father Kearney | |
| Father Snivly | until 1868 |
| Rev. M.E. Tracy | 1868-1871 |
| Rev. Joh Donnelly | 1871-1874 |
| Rev. John Ruddy | 1878-1888 |
| Rev. Father Lynch | 1888-1889 |
| Father Dwyer | 1889 |
| Rev. P.M. Cauley | 1889-1893 |
| Rev. Thomas Graham | 1893-1897 |
| Father Miller | 1897 |
| Rev. John F. Butler | 1897-1928 |
| Rev. John A. McAndrew | 1928 |
Simon Spellacy
Robert Robinson
William Englehoupt
James McGuire
John Clancy
MIchael McCarthy
Tim Clark
Daniel and James Boyle
Felix Duffy
Martin Welsh
Father Cody
Father McGovern